The Island Cinema High quality family entertainment. 535 Tarpon Bay R Sanibel, FL 33957
(239) 472-1701. The Island Cinema has been a Sanibel tradition and landmark. Theater is alive and well here on Sanibel Island and Fort Myers. Very cute theater. Comfy seats, only about 5 seats per row and an aisle on one side only. They have about 3 movies at a time. Definitely recommend it for a rainy or overcast day if you're staying in Sanibel. Movie listings, trailers, reviews, showtimes, pictures, theatres and movie times.